Flag of Germany

Quick Hits

  • The general works council’s right to codetermine the use of a company-wide time tracking system does not automatically cover the information rights of local works councils.
  • A general works council may regulate local works councils’ access to personal working time data only if the local works councils have authorized it to do so.
  • Permanent read-only access to working time data for works councils can raise data protection concerns if the reasons for various employee absences allow conclusions about employees’ health.

The Case: Read-Only Access to Working Time Data

The employer had concluded a company-wide works agreement with its general works council on the human resources management system “LOGA.” The employer used the system to record working hours, time accounts, and reasons for absence, among other things. The local works councils received electronic read-only access to the system for monitoring purposes.

A data protection incident triggered the dispute. A local works council had employees’ sick days compiled in an unencrypted spreadsheet file on an internal drive. In response, the employer revoked the access rights of all local works councils.

The general works council demanded that access be restored. In the alternative, it requested limited access to the data without certain reasons for absence, such as information on illness, rehabilitation stays, or maternity leave.

No Right of the General Works Council to Enforce the Agreement

The LAG dismissed the appeal. The introduction and use of a time-tracking system that records data on employee conduct or performance is generally subject to codetermination under Section 87(1) No. 6 of the Works Constitution Act (Betriebsverfassungsgesetz (BetrVG)). Because the employer used the system throughout the company, the general works council was responsible for codetermination on its introduction and use.

However, the court found that this competence did not automatically cover every issue connected with the system. Local works councils’ access to working time data concerns their own monitoring and information rights under Section 80 of the BetrVG. Local works councils can exercise these rights at the establishment level, even when the system is used company-wide.

Under Section 50(2) of the BetrVG, the local works councils would have had to delegate the exercise of their rights under Section 80 of the BetrVG to the general works council for a company-wide rule. There was no such delegation.

The LAG left open the question of whether employers can generally grant local works councils their own access rights in a company-wide works agreement. In any case, the employer could not implement the agreement in favor of the local works councils. Read-only access would create not only rights but also data protection obligations for the local works councils. The local works councils had not agreed to take on these obligations.

Data Protection Limits on Permanent Access

Even read-only access is a processing of personal data under the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).

The stored reasons for absence were particularly sensitive. Information on rehabilitation stays or maternity leave allowed conclusions about the health of the employees concerned. This made it health data. As a result, the stricter requirements of Article 9 of the GDPR and Section 26(3) of the Federal Data Protection Act (Bundesdatenschutzgesetz (BDSG)) applied.

In the court’s view, permanent access to these records for monitoring purposes, without any specific reason, was not necessary. Section 80(2) of the BetrVG gives works councils a right to the information and the documents they need to perform their duties. However, this does not include permanent online access to an entire database.

In response to a specific request for information, an employer can examine which data the council actually needs for the task at hand. Unlimited system access would largely eliminate this right of review.

The company-wide works agreement did not justify the access either. Processing the specially protected data was not necessary in the employment context, and the employees concerned had not consented.

No Right to a New Data View

The alternative request also failed. The existing agreement did not provide for access that hid individual reasons for absences. In addition, the employer would first have had to commission programming for this limited view. The works councils’ right to information under Section 80 of the BetrVG did not go that far.

According to the court, the right to information does not require an employer to create new documents or to technically modify an existing system.

Outlook and Takeaways

This decision does not mean that works councils may never receive working time data. However, the court drew a clear line between information needed for a specific case and permanent, comprehensive system access. The court also made clear that Section 87(1) No. 6 of the BetrVG alone does not allow a general works council to regulate local works councils’ access to personal data for monitoring purposes.

Companies may want to review access authorization concepts for human resources and time-tracking systems regularly. Access protocols may be role-based, purpose-limited, and designed to minimize data. A general works agreement also cannot change these principles.

Ogletree Deakins’ Munich office will continue to monitor developments and will provide updates on the Cross-Border, Cybersecurity and Privacy, and Germany blogs as additional information becomes available.

Follow and Subscribe
LinkedIn | Instagram | Webinars | Podcasts


Close up of American visa label in passport. Shallow depth of field.

The court vacated the final rule on the grounds that it was arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, and otherwise not in accordance with law, finding that DHS had not adequately considered the existing Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS) or justified the costs and burden of a new system, and that DHS exceeded its statutory authority by placing limitations on academic activity that are not reasonably related to the nature or purpose of F-1 classification.

Quick Hits

  • The rule would have admitted F-1 students and J-1 exchange visitors for up to four years, requiring them to apply for extensions of stay before their admission period expired.
  • The existing duration-of-status framework remains in place for eligible F-1 students and J-1 exchange visitors.

Published on July 17, 2026, the DHS final rule sought to replace the “duration of status” admission period with a fixed admission period and expiration date. Under the duration of status framework (notated as “D/S” on Form I-94, an individual’s arrival/departure record), eligible F-1 students and J-1 exchange visitors were generally able to remain in the United States for their authorized studies or exchange programs while properly maintaining their F-1 or J-1 status. In addition to requiring individuals to file extension applications before their fixed admission periods expired, the rule included restrictions on seeking additional degrees and changing academic fields.

The court found that DHS had not properly evaluated costs and benefits, considered less burdensome alternatives, or adequately addressed concerns raised during the public comment period. For example, the court found that DHS had not sufficiently considered leveraging or improving its existing system, SEVIS, for the reporting and monitoring associated with addressing DHS’s fraud or national security concerns. DHS also had not explained how a discretionary admission renewal system would address fraud concerns or outweigh the costs of replacing SEVIS and the existing framework. Lastly, the court ruled that DHS’s restrictions on joint degrees, changes in academic concentrations, and the pursuit of additional degrees at the same or lower academic level were not reasonably related to the nature or purpose of the F-1 visa program.

A coalition of higher education and labor groups challenged the final rule in Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security, No. 1:26-cv-13799-FDS (D. Mass.). Earlier, the court granted a preliminary injunction on September 14, 2026, to prevent the final rule’s implementation while litigation continued. DHS appealed that preliminary injunction to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit. That appeal remains pending and is separate from the recent November 16, 2026, decision and vacatur by the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts.

Key Takeaways

The vacated rule’s fixed admission periods and related restrictions cannot be implemented unless the judgment is changed through further court proceedings. Students and exchange visitors must still properly maintain status and comply with all reporting, employment authorization, and academic program requirements.

Ogletree Deakins’ Immigration Practice Group will continue to monitor developments and will provide updates on the Higher Education and Immigration blogs as additional information becomes available.

This article and more information on how the Trump administration’s actions impact employers can be found on Ogletree Deakins’ Administration Resource Hub.

Follow and Subscribe
LinkedIn | Instagram | Webinars | Podcasts


State Flag of California

Quick Hits

  • The California Consumer Privacy Act requires businesses to adhere to certain notice, opt-out, and access requirements when they use automated tools to make significant decisions impacting consumers.
  • The regulations concerning ADMTs will impact notice and disclosure requirements and operational workflows. The use of an ADMT for a significant decision concerning a consumer also triggers a risk assessment under the CCPA, so preparing for compliance now is key.
  • The ADMT regulations will take effect January 1, 2027.

The CCPA requires employers to notify job applicants, employees, and independent contractors before using automated decision-making technology to make significant decisions in employment decisions, including recruiting, hiring, scheduling, promotions, disciplinary actions, and dismissals. For example, this may include AI tools that handle resume screening, applicant scoring, video interview analysis, and performance ratings.

The core obligations under the ADMT regulations include a pre-use notice, opt-out right, and access rights. The pre-use notice must clearly describe in specific terms how the technology will be used. It must explain the purpose of using the ADMT, the types of personal information used, how to opt out or whether an exception applies, and any human role in decision-making. The notice must be accessible to people with disabilities.

The law requires businesses to allow consumers to opt out of the use of automated decision-making technology, but lists narrow circumstances in which a business is not required to provide the opt-out right if it meets certain conditions. Exceptions include: (1) if the business provides the consumer with a method to appeal the decision to a human reviewer with authority to overturn the tool’s decision; (2) when a business uses an ADMT only to assess a consumer’s ability to perform at work or in an educational program to determine whether to admit, accept, or hire the individual, and the technology works for the business’s purpose without unlawfully discriminating based on protected characteristics; and (3) the ADMT is used solely for allocating or assigning work or for compensation if the technology works for the business’s purpose without unlawfully discriminating based on protected characteristics.

A business that uses an ADMT to make a significant decision must provide consumers with a clear explanation of the specific purpose for using the ADMT, how the ADMT processed their personal information to generate a specific output, and the outcome of the decision-making process, including how the output was used to make a significant decision.

Next Steps

Employers may want to closely review the regulations to confirm that compliance obligations are met since they include specific details on each requirement. Businesses using ADMTs to make significant decisions prior to January 1, 2027, must be in compliance with the requirements by January 1, 2027. Businesses using ADMT on or after January 1, 2027, must be in compliance immediately.

Businesses may wish to take adequate steps to be prepared to lawfully respond to opt-out requests, requests to appeal to a human reviewer, requests to access, and complaints alleging an automated decision-making technology discriminated based on a protected characteristic, such as race or gender.

The California attorney general and the California Privacy Protection Agency (CPPA) will handle enforcement of these rules. For 2025-2026, businesses that violate the CCPA may be subject to fines of up to $2,633 per violation or up to $7,988 per each intentional violation. The CPPA adjusts the penalty amounts biannually in January of every odd-numbered year.

Finally, businesses that are considering purchasing AI-powered software applications for a particular use may want to make sure they will be able to comply with these regulations before acquiring the software.

Ogletree Deakins’ California offices and Artificial Intelligence and Innovation Practice Group will continue to monitor developments and will post updates on the Artificial Intelligence and Innovation, California, and Cybersecurity and Privacy blogs as additional information becomes available.

Anne Yarovoy Khan is a shareholder in Ogletree Deakins’ San Francisco office.

Sean P. Nalty is a shareholder in Ogletree Deakins’ San Francisco office.

This article was co-authored by Leah J. Shepherd, who is a writer in Ogletree Deakins’ Washington, D.C., office.

Follow and Subscribe
LinkedIn | Instagram | Webinars | Podcasts


Quick Hits

  • In Patterson v. WEX Inc., the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California partially denied a motion to dismiss claims that a third-party administrator violated state law by overcharging platform users for processing payments for COBRA coverage.
  • The court found that a reasonable consumer could be deceived by the nature of the vendor’s fee disclosures, including a delayed disclosure about an online payment processing fee.
  • The court denied the plaintiff’s request for injunctive relief and restitution under two state laws, but left open the possibility of equitable relief and damages under a third state law.

Many employers use third-party administrators (TPAs) to administer their Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA) plans, monitor qualifying events that trigger COBRA, send legally required notices, process enrollments, send invoices, and collect payments. COBRA stipulates that the maximum amount that can be charged for COBRA coverage is the entire monthly premium, plus an administrative fee that’s no more than 2 percent of the monthly premium.

Background

A California plaintiff brought a proposed class action against WEX Inc., which provides an online platform for administering COBRA coverage, alleging fraud, unjust enrichment, and violations of the California Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA), the California Unfair Competition Law (UCL), and the California False Advertising Law (FAL). The plaintiff claimed WEX had charged platform users fees that exceeded statutory maximums, delayed disclosure of a processing fee, and incorrectly characterized certain fees, all for the coverage period of July 2025.

WEX’s platform allows users to pay via recurring debit card or ACH payments, one-time online payments, or check or money order sent by mail. Recurring debit card or ACH payments and payments sent by mail do not incur processing fees, but each one-time online payment incurs a $20 processing fee in addition to a 2 percent administrative fee. For example, a consumer paying for three months of insurance premiums via one-time online payments on the same day would incur three processing fees totaling $60.

The plaintiff claimed that WEX did not disclose the processing fee until the final payment screen and failed to inform platform users of alternative forms of payment by which the processing fee could be avoided. He also claimed that his monthly premium was $804.11, so the $20 processing fee was 2.5 percent of his premium, exceeding the statutory limit.

WEX moved to dismiss all claims, arguing that no reasonable consumer could proceed through its platform without becoming aware of the processing fee and that the lawsuit failed to identify any false or misleading statement or advertisement. It also argued that the CLRA did not apply because insurance coverage does not constitute goods or services under the CLRA, and that the named plaintiff did not have standing for injunctive relief.

The District Court’s Ruling

The federal district court noted that conduct violates the CLRA if it is “likely to deceive,” meaning “it is probable that a significant portion of the general consuming public or of targeted consumers, acting reasonably in the circumstances, could be misled.”

Reviewing WEX’s Rule 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim, the court concluded that the plaintiff had plausibly alleged that a reasonable consumer was likely to be deceived by WEX’s characterization of the processing fee or the delayed disclosure. The processing fee disclosure appeared only after a platform user signed up for COBRA, created a profile, saw the amount for the next payment, which did not include the processing fee, and then selected “make payment” rather than “recurring payments.” The court found the plaintiff had plausibly alleged a CLRA claim based on WEX’s deceptively characterizing the processing fee as a necessary fee for online payments when it was an additional charge unrelated to the individual’s transaction.

In addition, the court found that the CLRA applied because WEX processes payments online and sells that service to platform users.

As to the unjust enrichment claim, the court found that it “remains a matter of some dispute,” but “there is no basis to dismiss it here where underlying claims remain.”

Meanwhile, the court found the plaintiff failed to establish standing for injunctive relief under the UCL and FAL because he did not show that he might use WEX’s platform in the future or would like to. Consumers who know or suspect that a company’s advertising was false at the time of the original purchase may establish standing for injunctive relief by plausibly alleging that (1) they would like to purchase the product in the future but cannot rely on the product’s advertising or labeling, or (2) they reasonably assumed the product was improved and might purchase the product in the future.

The court also rejected the plaintiff’s claim for restitution under the UCL and FAL, as he had “not pleaded facts plausibly establishing that legal remedies [were] inadequate.” The court granted the plaintiff leave to amend the claim because he “may be able to allege an intent to purchase” coverage in the future.

For multistate employers, compliance related to COBRA administrative fees may be complicated, as state laws vary in scope with respect to consumer protections barring unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts by corporations. Federal COBRA only applies to private employers with at least twenty employees. If a plan participant works for a smaller employer, the participant’s COBRA continuation coverage is governed by state “mini-COBRA” laws, meaning state law controls any fee disputes.

In some cases, employers may not be able to directly control the processing fees or administrative fees charged by TPAs. However, employers may be able to have an impact on fee amounts through contract negotiations, vendor selection processes, or bundling several plan types with one vendor.

Next Steps

Employers may wish to coordinate with third-party administrators to ensure that any COBRA administrative fees comply with state and federal laws and consumer protections. Employers and plan administrators that violate the fee cap for COBRA coverage may be subject to fines of up to $100 per day per affected individual.

Ogletree Deakins’ Employee Benefits and Executive Compensation Practice Group will continue to monitor developments and will provide updates on the California, Class Action, Employee Benefits and Executive Compensation, Healthcare, and Multistate Compliance blogs as additional information becomes available.

Eric P. Mathisen is a shareholder in Ogletree Deakins’ Salt Lake City office.

Timothy J. Stanton is a shareholder in Ogletree Deakins’ Chicago office.

This article was co-authored by Leah J. Shepherd, who is a writer in Ogletree Deakins’ Washington, D.C., office.

Follow and Subscribe
LinkedIn | Instagram | Webinars | Podcasts


Blurred motion of energetic businesspeople on the go and project team members discussing ideas in a conference room.

Quick Hits

  • The DOL issued a new final independent contractor rule, adopting an “economic reality” test that looks at a worker’s dependence on an employer.
  • The rule identifies the worker’s control over their work and their potential for profit or loss as primary factors for determining independent contractor status.
  • Companies using independent contractors need to review their classifications and compliance with the new rule to avoid potential liabilities.

The final rule, “Employee or Independent Contractor Status Under the Fair Labor Standards Act, Family and Medical Leave Act, and Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act,” formally rescinds the 2024 rule and replaces it with an analysis that tracks a prior rule issued in 2021, during President Donald Trump’s first term.

The final rule from the DOL Wage and Hour Division follows a notice of proposed rulemaking issued in February 2026, which the department noted received approximately 16,500 comments during the sixty-day comment period. The final rule tracks that proposed rule, focusing on an “economic reality” test and core factors, while expanding and reorganizing the illustrative examples in the rule.

Economic Reality Test

Like the 2021 rule, the final rule adopts an “economic reality” test to determine whether a worker may be classified as an independent contractor under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) and case law. The test turns on whether the worker is in business for himself or herself (an independent contractor) or is “economically dependent on an employer for work” (an employee).

Core Factors

The final rule identifies two “core factors” under the economic reality test:

  1. “nature and degree of control over the work”—This factor analyzes the extent to which a worker “exercises substantial control over key aspects of the performance of the work,” such as schedule, selection of projects, and freedom to work for other companies, including competitor companies.
  2. “individual’s opportunity for profit or loss”—This factor looks at whether a worker “has an opportunity to earn profits or incur losses based on his or her exercise of initiative (such as managerial skill or business acumen or judgment) or management of his or her investment in or capital expenditure.”

Additionally, the final rule identifies other factors that may be considered: (1) “the amount of skill required for the work”; (2) “the degree of permanence of the working relationship”; and (3) “whether the work is part of an integrated unit of production.” The final rule states that additional factors may be considered, but only if they are relevant to whether the worker is in business for him- or herself rather than economically dependent.

Next Steps

The adoption of the final rule provides employers and workers with greater certainty over whether a worker or group of workers may be properly classified as independent contractors under the law. The DOL argues that this final rule is more consistent with the FLSA and case law interpreting independent contractor status and provides greater clarity.

The rule stems from concerns that the 2024 Rule’s confusing and sometimes overlapping factors have generally resulted in more workers being classified as independent contractors, potentially even in more situations than the law requires. The final rule instead streamlines the analysis, focusing on the “economic reality” of the situation and two core factors. However, it is possible the final rule could face legal challenges.

The final rule is set to take effect sixty days following the rule’s formal publication in the Federal Register.

Companies that use independent contractors may want to assess their current worker classifications and review their written contracts, policies, and practices to ensure that workers classified as independent contractors meet the requirements for such classification under the final rule and federal law. At the same time, companies should continue to consider the sometimes more stringent requirements for independent-contractor classification under certain state laws. Misclassification of workers may face fines or liability for unpaid wages, overtime pay, unpaid taxes, or workers’ compensation.

Ogletree Deakins’ Wage and Hour Practice Group will continue to monitor developments and will provide updates on the Class Action, Trucking and Logistics, and Wage and Hour blogs as new information becomes available. This article and more information on how the Trump administration’s actions impact employers can be found on Ogletree Deakins’ Administration Resource Hub.

Information on state and federal independent contractor laws is also available on the Ogletree Deakins Client Portal. The Client Portal will provide updates in the Federal Independent Contractors law summary. Snapshots and updates are available for all registered client users. Detailed information is available for Premium and Advanced subscribers. For more information on the Client Portal or a Client Portal subscription, please reach out to clientportal@ogletree.com.

Follow and Subscribe
LinkedIn | Instagram | Webinars | Podcasts


Quick Hits

  • Choosing the country and employment structure: Employers planning on starting operations in Europe will want to consider not only the ease of entering a European country but the ease of exiting it as well, and weigh the tradeoffs of a local entity, branch, employer of record (EOR), or nonresident employer (NRE) registration.
  • Assessing the local law landscape: Before making a first hire, successful employers will take a deep dive into the local employment law landscape to understand the complexities of compliance with even a single hire.
  • Preparing for day one: Some obligations apply with the very first employee, while others are triggered by headcount, and the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) requires clear notice and a lawful basis before employers collect any candidate and employee data.

Multiple factors can motivate U.S. companies to enter new markets—from supporting new client contracts and accessing engineering, research, and development talent to building nearshore or offshore capacity. The European focus is understandable: The region offers deep, and sometimes less expensive, talent pools, and—in some countries—entering the market can be relatively easy. A key takeaway, however, is that a U.S. hiring playbook does not travel well in Europe.

In the United States, many employers can hire quickly with a standard offer letter, a familiar set of screening tools, and policies that can be rolled out over time. In Europe, the picture is different. Before hiring employees in Europe, employers may want to prepare to address three critical issues: (1) choosing the right country and employment structure, (2) understanding the employment law landscape and what it takes to hire compliantly, and (3) preparing for day one.

Issue 1: Choosing the Right Country and Employment Structure

Country selection should be assessed jurisdiction by jurisdiction. Employers will want to ask how easy it is to enter and, just as important, exit each country. The wind-down process should not be an afterthought. Entering many European markets can be relatively straightforward, but practical steps such as opening a local bank account are often tricky. Employers will also want to understand how many policies, registrations, and other requirements apply on day one, and the process to terminate employees.

Once a country is selected, the employer must choose among several possibilities for how it will actually employ people.

  • A local entity—a separately incorporated local legal entity—is best suited for a sustained, long-term presence with direct control, but it requires a registered office, accounting, and tax and payroll compliance, and it has the longest timeline.
  • A branch is an extension of the U.S. parent and may involve simpler registration in some jurisdictions, but it exposes the parent company to direct liability.
  • An employer of record (EOR)—a third-party employer that hires staff on the company’s behalf—offers fast entry and a way to test a market, but it comes with ongoing fees and joint-employment risk, and some jurisdictions restrict or heavily regulate EOR use.
  • Another option, registering as nonresident employer (NRE), offers a middle ground: the U.S. company registers directly as the employer without building out a full local subsidiary. If an EOR is dipping a toe in the water, NRE registration is getting waist deep—though it is not always available. In some countries a tax identification number and other formal registrations are required, which can take time and money to complete. Even if registration requirements are minimal, employers will need local payroll and compliance support, and the arrangement may raise permanent establishment (PE) tax exposure.

Timing matters, too. Entity and branch formation can take anywhere from a couple of weeks to several months, depending on the jurisdiction and registrar backlog. EOR and NRE arrangements can be live in days to a few weeks, but the tradeoff for that speed is ongoing fees and PE or joint-employer exposure.

Issue 2: Assessing the Local Law Landscape

Before making a first hire, successful employers will take a deep dive into the local employment law landscape. Many European countries provide generous statutory leave entitlements; impose notice, severance, and process requirements that make termination difficult; and give employees strong collective voice through works councils and unions that may need to be informed or consulted on workplace changes. Just as important is the compliance burden: Employers will want to understand the complexities of ongoing compliance and how many steps—e.g., registrations, policies, notices, and localized documents—are required to be compliant with even a single hire. That burden shows up at every stage of the hiring process, from the job posting to the employment agreement.

Leave is often the first surprise. Unlike in the United States, where employees generally have no legal entitlement to vacation, European countries require employers to provide minimum statutory leave, and some regimes are very generous—including twenty to thirty days of mandatory vacation, ten to fifteen public holidays, months or even years of company-paid sick days, bereavement leave, and even leave for special occasions such as the birth of a child, a wedding, or moving house. Many jurisdictions also require employers to allow employees to carry over unused leave and to pay out accrued but unused leave on termination of employment. These entitlements affect not only cost, but also coverage and productivity planning for a small team.

Employee representation rules can also shape how quickly an employer can act. In some countries, works councils or unions must be informed or consulted before new policies are rolled out or before significant workplace changes are made, and these bodies may become mandatory once headcount thresholds are reached. Even decisions that seem routine to a U.S. employer—such as introducing a new policy or changing terms and conditions—may require a consultation process and, in some cases, employee consent. U.S. employers may want to factor these timelines into their plans rather than discovering them after they have grown.

The ability to exit employees deserves equal attention. Outside the United States, at-will employment generally does not exist, and the employment relationship is governed by an employment agreement and local statute. Many jurisdictions default to indefinite contracts and restrict when and how fixed-term contracts may be used or renewed before they automatically convert to indefinite employment. Dismissing an employee may require a valid reason, notice, severance, and a prescribed process, and the risk of claims can be significant. Probationary periods offer some flexibility, but their length and permitted extensions vary widely, and some jurisdictions require probationary terms to be spelled out in the contract itself. Employers that understand how difficult it will be to end the relationship before hiring will be better positioned to structure it correctly from the start.

Issue 3: Preparing for Day One

Day one obligations, which can apply to the first employee hired, are also an important factor to consider. In Belgium, for example, work rules must be registered on day one, and Ireland imposes health and safety standards from the first hire. Other obligations are triggered by headcount—with work rules or works councils becoming mandatory once certain employee thresholds are reached. Depending on the policy type, some jurisdictions also require works council or union consultation before rollout, government registration, or local-language translation. Employers may want to map headcount-triggered obligations before they hire, not after they cross the threshold.

Data privacy requires equal attention. The GDPR requires a lawful basis and clear notice before collecting candidate and employee data. Consent forms often need to be jurisdiction-specific rather than a repurposed U.S. or global template, and obligations may be enhanced for cross-border transfers of data back to the United States. Employers may also want to confirm that existing tools work locally—for example, that the code of conduct hotline supports the new country’s language(s) and local phone numbers before go-live.

A Europe-Ready Strategy

U.S. employers considering their first hire in Europe may want to ensure their approach:

  • confirms the structure (entity, branch, EOR, or NRE) before a single job is posted;
  • localizes employment agreements rather than translating a U.S. template;
  • maps headcount-triggered obligations before hiring;
  • builds immigration and work-authorization timelines into the hiring plan;
  • confirms what can (and cannot) be asked of candidates and the types of information that may be sought from references and in background checks; and
  • puts mandatory policies and data privacy notices in place before day one, where required.

Hiring a first employee in Europe is not simply a matter of extending a U.S. offer letter across the Atlantic. Employers that plan for country selection, employment structure, day-one obligations, and local hiring rules from the outset will be best-positioned to build a compliant European workforce.

Ogletree Deakins’ Cross-Border Practice Group will continue to monitor developments and will post updates on the Cross-Border blog as additional information becomes available.

Shirin (Aboujawde) Gudgin is a shareholder in the New York office of Ogletree Deakins, and a partner in the firm’s London office.

Peg Ventricelli, a practice assistant in the Stamford office of Ogletree Deakins, contributed to this article.

Follow and Subscribe
LinkedIn | Instagram | Webinars | Podcasts


Quick Hits

  • On November 17, 2026, the DOL proposed changes to the PERM labor certification process that would replace the requirement to announce open positions in print newspaper advertising with at least ninety days of online and in-person recruitment that mirrors how an employer fills comparable positions.
  • Employers that laid off U.S. workers in the same or similar occupation and area within the prior two years would not be permitted to file PERM applications for those positions.
  • Schedule A would be eliminated, so employers sponsoring nurses and physical therapists would need to complete the full PERM process.
  • Comments are due January 19, 2027.

The proposal would lengthen and modernize recruitment, restrict sponsorship by employers that have conducted layoffs, and eliminate the Schedule A exemption for nurses and physical therapists.

Background

PERM labor certification is the first step for most U.S. employers sponsoring foreign nationals for permanent residence (individuals holding a “green card”) in the EB-2 and EB-3 categories. Before filing, the employer must test the U.S. labor market and show that no able, willing, qualified, and available U.S. workers applied for the position. DOL states that the current rules no longer reflect how employers recruit and that they allow some employers to recruit for sponsored positions differently than for ordinary hires.

Key Proposed Changes

Recruitment. Employers would no longer place print newspaper advertisements. Instead, all positions would be advertised for at least ninety days through the state workforce agency, the employer’s careers website, online job boards, the employer’s customary social media channels, and a job fair or campus recruiting event. Advertisements would need to state the wage or wage range and whether the role is remote or hybrid. Recruitment would have to end thirty to sixty days before filing.

Comparability with ordinary hiring. Employers would attest, under penalty of perjury, that they recruited for the sponsored position through the same channels and in the same manner as for positions that do not involve sponsorship. PERM-specific application methods would be presumed not to be in good faith.

Layoffs. An employer that laid off U.S. workers in the same or similar occupation in the area of intended employment within the prior two years would not be permitted to file a PERM application for that position. Layoffs after filing would trigger notice obligations and require the employer to offer the position to affected workers. The current rule looks back only six months and does not bar filing.

Filing and documentation. Employers would submit their full recruitment record, including U.S. applicants’ résumés, with the application rather than only upon audit. The notice of filing would remain posted until the related immigrant petition is decided.

Schedule A. DOL would eliminate Schedule A, which currently allows employers sponsoring registered nurses, physical therapists, and individuals of exceptional ability in the sciences or arts to skip the labor market test.

Remote positions. DOL is asking for comment on whether fully remote positions should remain eligible for PERM sponsorship at all.

Next Steps

Comments are due  by January 19, 2027. DOL must consider the comments before issuing a final rule, which may differ from the proposal. A final rule would take effect sixty days after publication in the Federal Register, and applications filed within a short transition period after that date would remain subject to the current rules.

Ogletree Deakins’ Immigration Practice Group will continue to monitor developments and will post updates on the Immigration blog as additional information becomes available.

Follow and Subscribe
LinkedIn | Instagram | Webinars | Podcasts


State Flag of California

Quick Hits

  • Cal/OSHA has proposed regulations to enforce new egregious and “enterprise-wide” violation categories that could substantially increase penalties for California employers.
  • Egregious violations could result in separate willful citations and penalties for each employee exposed to a hazard when aggravating circumstances are present.
  • Enterprise-wide violations could allow Cal/OSHA to multiply penalties across multiple worksites based on a company policy or pattern of violations.
  • Written comments are due November 30, 2026, and a public hearing is scheduled for December 3, 2026.

The violation types were introduced in 2021 under Senate Bill (SB) 606, which amended Labor Code section 6317 and added Labor Code section 6317.8 to require that Cal/OSHA issue citations for “Enterprise-wide” and “Egregious” violations. Cal/OSHA’s move signals an intent to begin enforcement of these categories and could greatly increase employer regulatory exposure in defined circumstances.

A public hearing is set for Thursday, December 3, 2026, and written comments are due Monday, November 30, 2026.

Egregious violations proposals

Cal/OSHA’s proposal defines an egregious violation as a willful violation accompanied by one or more aggravating circumstances within a five-year lookback. The definition of a willful violation remains unchanged and would require that an employer either consciously act in violation of a safety law or take no reasonable effort to eliminate a hazardous or unsafe condition of which the employer is aware. Under proposed section 334(f) the violation would also be considered egregious if one of more of the following circumstances are alleged to be true:

  • A history of final Repeat, Willful, or Egregious violations, five or more Serious violations, or ten or more General or Regulatory violations
  • Intentional disregard of health and safety responsibilities, such as failing to maintain an operative Injury and Illness Prevention Program (IIPP)
  • Conduct that, taken as a whole, amounts to clear bad faith
  • A fatality, a “catastrophe” (inpatient hospitalization of three or more employees), five or more occupational injuries or illnesses, or an experience modifier above 125 percent

Once an egregious violation is established, the proposed regulatory language would require  Cal/OSHA to issue a separate citation and a separate proposed penalty for each instance of an employee exposed to the alleged violation. The proposed language defines an instance to mean a single employee’s exposure to the violation. Proposed section 334(j) goes on to provide that “if a violation exposes ten (10) employees to the hazard, there are ten (10) instances with ten (10) separate penalties.” This appears to mean that Cal/OSHA would issue ten citations, one per instance, each with a proposed willful penalty, which carries an $11,632 minimum and a $162,851 maximum per citation. Finally, egregious citations would also be ineligible for abatement credit.

Although limited to willful violations, the factors regarding bad faith and inoperative IIPPs would vest considerable discretion in Cal/OSHA as to whether to impose the egregious classification.

Enterprise-wide violations proposals

Of significance to employers with multiple worksites in the state, proposed section 334(g) would create a rebuttable presumption that a violation is enterprise-wide if the employer has employees at multiple worksites and either:

  1. the employer has a written policy or procedure that applies to more than one worksite and violates a safety and health standard, or
  2. Cal/OSHA has evidence of a pattern or practice of the same violation at more than one worksite.

The penalty implications flowing from an enterprise-wide violation are significant. Under proposed section 336(k), the proposed penalty is multiplied by the number of worksites covered by the citation, capped at $162,851. Several terms are important to note:

  • Only the classification that applies to every covered violation would be used to calculate the proposed penalty for the enterprise-wide violation. A Repeat, Willful, or Accident-Related characterization that does not apply across the board would be dropped for purposes of the penalty calculation.
  • The calculation presumes medium Severity and Extent and moderate Likelihood, though Cal/OSHA would retain discretion to depart from these presumptions.
  • The proposed penalty reductions are limited to the Size adjustment, and the 50 percent abatement credit for General and Serious violations would be available only if the employer were to resolve the hazard in a timely manner and submits the required documentation. (Despite the limitation set forth in 336(3)(13), the proposal states that “the adjustment factors of Good Faith, Size, and History will be assessed based on the worksites covered.” There is no guidance on how Cal/OSHA intends to resolve this apparent contradiction.)
  • For failure to abate, a separate penalty would apply to each worksite that did not timely abate, prorated based on how many worksites came into compliance.

The regulatory language is not without ambiguity. The language does not provide clear guidance on how it will be enforced or how an employer can rebut the presumption. For example, it is unclear whether the violation must relate only to the written document itself, rather than to its implementation. In other words, does an alleged failure to implement an otherwise compliant written program in one location trigger the presumption? To what extent does tailoring a written program to a specific worksite render the rule inapplicable? Similarly, it remains unclear to what extent “a pattern or practice” will differ substantively from a repeat violation.

One thing is clear: the presumption effectively means that Cal/OSHA would be empowered to cite an employer for violations at worksites not subject to an actual inspection.

Ogletree Deakins’ California offices and Workplace Safety and Health Practice Group will continue to monitor developments and provide updates on the California and Workplace Safety and Health blogs as additional information becomes available.

Follow and Subscribe
LinkedIn | Instagram | Webinars | Podcasts

 


State Flag of Texas

Quick Hits

  • DACA work benefits in Texas could depend on decisions by the incoming Texas attorney general to continue or withdraw from ongoing DACA litigation.
  • A federal judge’s decision on DACA termination in Texas remains pending, and the federal judge could issue a decision before the new Texas attorney general takes office, which could lead to further appeals.
  • Texas’s incoming attorney general has promised to review ongoing litigation involving Texas and has not confirmed continuing or withdrawing from ongoing DACA litigation, creating some uncertainty on continued or terminated DACA work benefits in Texas.

Where the DACA Litigation Stands With the State of Texas

In 2025, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled that DACA program protections against deportation and authorizing work benefits were unlawful. However, the Fifth Circuit Court limited potential remedies, including the termination of DACA work benefits, to the State of Texas. Right now, the litigants are awaiting a U.S. district judge’s implementing order on the final scope of DACA termination, which would implement the circuit court’s ruling in a final decision. (Please see our earlier article, “DACA Expected to Reopen: What Employers Need to Know About the Latest Legal Shift.”)

The Texas Attorney General Election and a Review of Pending Litigation

Texas voters recently elected Nathan Johnson as the state’s next attorney general, with the new attorney general entering office in January 2027. In public interviews, Johnson has promised a thorough review of ongoing litigation involving the State of Texas. He has confirmed an intent to strictly scrutinize ongoing “showpiece” litigation in the Texas Attorney General’s Office that he would consider not in the state’s interest to continue. However, the attorney general–elect has not identified specific areas of litigation or specific lawsuits that will receive higher scrutiny in making future litigation decisions.

Until Texas Attorney General–Elect Johnson confirms an intention to continue or withdraw from Texas’s ongoing litigation requesting DACA program termination, the timing of a final decision involving continued or terminated DACA work benefits will be uncertain. The attorney general–elect may withdraw Texas from ongoing DACA litigation, or, if the federal judge issues a decision on DACA’s termination before the new attorney general takes office, the new attorney general may not continue the litigation on appeal. While Texas’s future litigation posture is uncertain at present, it is unlikely that the attorney general–elect would continue federal litigation requesting DACA termination.

Looking Ahead

A federal judge’s ruling on the scope and terms of the DACA program’s termination could have an immediate impact on Texas workforces. While a decision to terminate DACA work benefits could be stayed pending appeal or motion for reconsideration, the ruling could be given immediate effect and require prompt action by Texas employers related to their employees who are DACA beneficiaries. Texas employers should remain aware that Texas’s litigation position could change next year, depending on the new attorney general’s decision to continue or withdraw from the DACA litigation. As a result of the recent election, a final resolution on DACA work benefits for Texas employees could take some time.

For now, Texas employers may want to consider the following:

  • continuing to accept unexpired employment authorization documents (EADs) held by DACA recipients (Category (c)(33));
  • tracking EAD expiration dates and reminding employees to apply for renewals 120 to 150 days prior to expiration; and
  • monitoring the litigation involving DACA termination, as a ruling terminating DACA work benefits could require immediate action by employers.

Ogletree Deakins’ Immigration Practice Group will continue to monitor developments and provide updates on the Immigration and Texas blogs as additional information becomes available.

Follow and Subscribe
LinkedIn | Instagram | Webinars | Podcasts


Quick Hits

  • The DOL’s final rule rescinds the affirmative action and EEO requirements under 29 CFR Part 30for registered apprenticeship programs and replaces them with a single requirement to comply with applicable federal and state nondiscrimination laws.
  • The final rule takes effect on January 5, 2027.
  • State Apprenticeship Agencies (SAAs) will have one year after that date to submit state plans showing that their apprenticeship-specific laws, regulations, and policies conform to the revised federal standard.

Under the final rule, sponsors are no longer required to:

  • maintain written affirmative action programs;
  • conduct utilization analyses comparing apprentice demographics by race, sex, and ethnicity against the relevant labor pool;
  • set utilization goals, including the 7 percent disability utilization goal;
  • invite apprentices to self-identify as having a disability;
  • conduct targeted outreach;
  • perform annual personnel process reviews;
  • designate an individual to manage the program’s EEO policy;
  • post an equal opportunity pledge; or
  • provide anti-harassment training.

Instead, the revised 29 CFR 30.3 requires sponsors to comply with all applicable federal and state laws prohibiting discrimination based on race, color, religion, national origin, sex, age, genetic information, and disability. As a practical matter, any apprenticeship sponsors below the fifteen-employee threshold set by Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 may no longer be subject to apprenticeship-specific federal EEO obligations.

Registration agencies will no longer investigate discrimination complaints. Instead, they will refer complainants to the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), a state fair employment practices agency, or another appropriate enforcement entity. Registration agencies may take enforcement action only after a final, non-appealable determination of a violation, which sponsors must disclose to their registration agency within sixty days. Separately, SAAs must submit state plans within one year of the final rule’s effective date, and the DOL identified state laws establishing compulsory affirmative action programs as examples of nonconforming requirements.

Previous Mandates

In 2016, the DOL finalized rules requiring all sponsors, regardless of size, to internally disseminate an equal opportunity policy, maintain a list of current recruitment sources, provide anti-harassment training to apprentices and journeyworkers who work with them, and establish a procedure for handling harassment complaints. Sponsors with five or more apprentices also had to maintain affirmative action programs.

The DOL concluded that the utilization goals and related requirements induced sponsors to make preferential decisions based on race, sex, and other demographic characteristics. The agency pointed out that Title VII contains no provision requiring employers or apprenticeship programs to adopt group-based preferences on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin.

According to the DOL, Title VII precludes courts and agencies from requiring preferential treatment to achieve or maintain demographic balance, although a court may, under section 706(g), impose “a narrowly tailored, time-limited affirmative action plan” to remedy intentional discrimination. The DOL tied its rescission of the disability goal to its parallel rescission of the Section 503 utilization goal.

As under Section 503, voluntary, lawful outreach remains permissible, while race- and sex-based numerical requirements are reframed as legal risk, rather than compliance obligations.

This final rule aligns with the Trump administration’s other actions with respect to diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives. To take just three recent examples, on July 21, 2026, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) issued a notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) to rescind federal equal employment opportunity (EEO) data reporting requirements, including employers’ requirements to report workforce demographic data by job category, sex, and race or ethnicity. On August 20, 2026, the DOL’s Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs (OFCCP) finalized a trio of rules rescinding race- and sex-based affirmative action regulations for federal contractors and modifying the Section 503 regulations. On October 16, 2026, EEOC requested that the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs (OIRA) review a final rule rescinding the interpretive portions of the EEOC’s version of the Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures (UGESP), 29 C.F.R. Part 1607.

Next Steps

Apprenticeship sponsors and SAAs may want to review their policies, program standards, and practices to ensure that recruiting, hiring, and other employment decisions do not depend on race, sex, or other protected characteristics, and that sponsors do not pursue numerical goals for particular demographic groups.

Sponsors must still comply with applicable federal, state, and local nondiscrimination laws. The final rule does not prohibit voluntary anti-harassment training or lawful outreach and recruitment efforts directed to all qualified individuals, and sponsors may continue targeted outreach to veterans.

Ogletree Deakins’ Workforce Analytics and Compliance Practice Group will continue to monitor developments and will provide updates on the Construction, Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Compliance, Government Contracting and Compliance, Higher Education, Manufacturing, and Workforce Analytics and Compliance blogs as additional information becomes available.

This article and more information on how the Trump administration’s actions impact employers can be found on Ogletree Deakins’ Administration Resource Hub.

T. Scott Kelly is a shareholder in Ogletree Deakins’ Birmingham and Washington, D.C., offices.

Cameron W. Ellis is of counsel in Ogletree Deakins’ Atlanta office.

This article was co-authored by Leah J. Shepherd, who is a writer in Ogletree Deakins’ Washington, D.C., office.

Follow and Subscribe
LinkedIn | Instagram | Webinars | Podcasts


Sign up to receive emails about new developments and upcoming programs.

Sign Up Now